California Mortgage Solutions
Compare two homes

Compare Two Homes Mortgage Calculator

Two homes can have very different monthly costs even when the prices look close. Enter each home's price, down payment, property tax, insurance and dues, add one rate and one term for both, and see the payment and the cash to close side by side, with the difference between them.

Compare two homes

Your numbers

The rate you have been quoted, or one you want to try. This field starts empty because we publish no rates.

Your assumption, not an offer. Pick the length you want to see the figures for.

Home A

What you expect to pay for this home. Property tax follows this figure, not the loan.

In dollars. The loan is the price less this amount.

California caps the base rate and local bonds sit on top of it, so the right figure belongs to the tax rate area the home is in.

A real premium depends on the home and the insurer. Use your own quote if you have one.

Put in the dues if the home belongs to an association, such as a condo or a planned development.

Lender, title, escrow and recording fees. Your Loan Estimate lists them after you apply.

Home B

What you expect to pay for this home. Property tax follows this figure, not the loan.

In dollars. The loan is the price less this amount.

California caps the base rate and local bonds sit on top of it, so the right figure belongs to the tax rate area the home is in.

A real premium depends on the home and the insurer. Use your own quote if you have one.

Put in the dues if the home belongs to an association, such as a condo or a planned development.

Lender, title, escrow and recording fees. Your Loan Estimate lists them after you apply.

Starting assumptions

Both homes use the same rate and term, and each uses its own tax rate, insurance, dues and closing costs. Mortgage insurance uses the starting assumption on this site, not a quote.

What that works out to

Home A and Home B compared, with the difference
Home AHome BDifference
Principal and interestNeeds a rateNeeds a rateNeeds a rate
Property taxes$733$825$92
Homeowners insurance$150$150$0
Mortgage insurance$0$0$0
HOA dues$0$0$0
Total each monthNeeds a rateNeeds a rateNeeds a rate
Cash to close$171,000$191,000$20,000

Cash to close here is the down payment plus the closing costs you entered. Credits, deposits and prepaid items are not counted.

An estimate from your figures. A lender's quote for either home will differ.

Enter the rate you have been quoted and the numbers appear. We do not publish rates.

These are estimates from the figures you entered, not a quote, an offer, or a commitment to lend.

A calculator works from the figures you typed into it. Your loan officer works from your file and your credit.

Ask us for a real quote

How the math works

Each home is worked separately. The loan is the price less the down payment, and principal and interest comes from the standard amortization formula, using the rate and term you chose for both homes.

Property tax is the price times that home's tax rate, divided by twelve, because for a purchase the price stands in for the assessed value. Homeowners insurance is the yearly figure divided by twelve, and HOA dues are already monthly.

Mortgage insurance is a share of the loan, charged in this estimate only while the loan is large against the value of the home. A home with a bigger down payment can drop it, which is one reason two homes of similar price can end up far apart each month.

The difference column is Home B less Home A on every line. Cash to close is the down payment plus the closing costs. The tool leaves out prepaid items, credits, deposits already made, moving costs, repairs and anything a lender asks for after reviewing your file.

Starting assumptions

Everything here starts from round figures so the tool has something to show. They are not about either home. The second home opens at a higher price than the first only so the two columns differ, and you can change any figure.

These are estimates from the figures you entered, not a quote, an offer, or a commitment to lend.

Questions about comparing homes

Why do property tax and HOA dues change the comparison?

They are part of what you pay every month, and they differ from one home to the next even when prices are close. A home with a lower price but dues from an association, or a higher tax rate in its area, can cost as much each month as a pricier home without them. Comparing principal and interest alone leaves those out.

How does California property tax work on a purchase?

California sets a base rate by law and resets the assessed value to roughly the purchase price when a home is bought. Local voter-approved bonds and assessments are added on top, and they vary by the tax rate area the home sits in. That is why the tax rate is a field for each home: the same price can carry a different bill in a different neighborhood.

Why is the cash to close different for each home?

Cash to close starts with the down payment, so a bigger down payment means more cash. Closing costs also move with the price and the loan. A home that is cheaper each month can need more cash up front, or the other way around, so it helps to look at both figures together.

What else should I compare besides the payment?

Think about repairs the home may need, how old the roof and systems are, the cost of insurance in that area, commute and everyday costs, and how long you expect to stay. Ask your loan officer how the loan program you are considering treats each home, since property type and occupancy can change the terms.

Pick the question you are trying to answer

  • Monthly payment

    What leaves your account each month once taxes, insurance and dues are inside the figure.

  • Affordability

    What your income carries once your debts, the taxes and the insurance come out of it.

  • Refinance break-even

    The month the closing costs are paid back, and what the new loan costs over its life.

  • Amortization schedule

    Every payment, split into interest and principal, year by year.

  • DSCR check

    Whether a rental's rent covers its own payment, taxes, insurance and dues.

  • Rent vs buy

    What renting costs against what owning costs over the years you plan to stay, with the sale at the end counted.

  • HELOC payment

    The monthly figure on a HELOC balance at the rate you were quoted.

  • Closing costs

    Add up the lines on a Loan Estimate and see what the credits take off.

  • Down payment tool

    Four down payment amounts side by side: the loan, the mortgage insurance, the monthly total and the cash needed.

  • Debt-to-income calculator

    Your monthly debts set against your monthly income, as a housing ratio and a total ratio.

  • Cash to close calculator

    The cash you would bring to the closing table: down payment and closing costs, less your deposit and credits.

  • Mortgage quote comparison

    Two or three quotes on one loan, side by side, on what each costs up front and over the time you expect to keep the loan.

  • Loan scenario comparison

    Two or three versions of one purchase side by side, each with its own down payment, term, rate and points.

  • ARM vs fixed-rate comparison

    An adjustable-rate loan (ARM) next to a fixed-rate loan: the payment now, the payment after the opening period and the total paid.

  • Buy before you sell calculator

    What carrying two homes costs each month, and what is left from the sale of the first.

  • Extra payments calculator

    See how an extra payment each month changes the time to pay off a mortgage and the interest along the way.

  • Savings goal planner

    How much to set aside each month to reach a down payment and closing cost goal within the months you choose.

  • California escrow timeline planner

    The dates that follow the day your offer is accepted: deposit, contingencies and close of escrow.

A quote needs your file

Send us what you are working with, and your loan officer can price it for your file.

No credit pull to get started. This is not a commitment to lend. Equal Housing Opportunity.