Equity, and the cap on the new loan
A cash-out refinance borrows against your equity: the appraised value of the home less what you owe on it. Each program caps the new loan at a share of that value, set by the agency and sometimes lowered by the lender, and the cap turns on whether the home is your principal residence, a second home or a rental, how many units it has, and the program. FHA measures its cap against the property's adjusted value and VA against the reasonable value on its notice of value, which is why an appraisal is part of a cash-out refinance. Any part of a VA funding fee that would push the loan over the home's value must be paid in cash at closing. The cap decides how much you can take out, and the appraiser, not the borrower or the broker, sets the value it is measured against.
How long you have owned the home, and your payment history
Each program requires you to have owned the home, and under some programs to have made payments on the loan being refinanced, for a period the agency sets before a cash-out refinance can close. Fannie Mae asks that at least one borrower has been on title for a period its guide sets, measured to the day the new loan funds, and that the loan being paid off has been in place for a period of its own; there is no wait for a home you inherited, and a borrower who bought recently without a mortgage can recover the documented purchase money under Fannie Mae's delayed financing rules. Freddie Mac's Guide carries rules of the same kind. FHA requires the home to have been owned and occupied as your principal residence for a period HUD sets before the case number is assigned, with an exception for an inherited home never treated as a rental, every mortgage payment made within the month due over a look-back period HUD sets, and a minimum number of payments on the current loan; a home owned free and clear can be refinanced as cash-out. A VA loan being refinanced must be seasoned for the period federal law sets. A late mortgage payment inside FHA's look-back takes the file out of automated approval and into manual underwriting.
Occupancy, and the program each file fits
A conventional loan sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac allows a cash-out refinance on your principal residence, a second home or an investment property, with the cap and the credit requirement differing by which it is. FHA permits cash-out refinances only on an owner-occupied principal residence, and will not count a non-occupant co-borrower's income or the rent from an accessory dwelling unit on a one-unit home toward qualifying. VA requires that you live in the home being refinanced, or return to it after major alterations, and a spouse may satisfy that for a veteran on active duty. A cash-out refinance of a rental you do not live in can also be written as a DSCR loan, qualified on the rent, or as a bank statement loan, qualified on your deposits; credit to acquire, improve or maintain such a rental is business-purpose under Regulation Z, outside the regulation's consumer rules, and each lender sets its own terms for it.
The costs, and when it does not pay
A refinance re-closes the whole first mortgage, so it carries the full set of refinance costs, and in a cash-out refinance they can be financed into the new loan, which means you pay interest on them. The Federal Reserve's consumer guide puts the test plainly: estimate how long it would take to recover the refinancing costs, and if you expect to move before then, the savings may not exceed the costs. Our refinance calculator works the break-even out from your own numbers. The new rate applies to the whole balance, not only to the cash, so whether a cash-out refinance or a second mortgage that leaves the first alone costs less turns on your current rate, how much you need and how long you will keep the loan; the HELOC comparison on this site sets the two side by side. And if the cash would pay off other debts, the CFPB's caution applies: you are taking out one loan to repay another, and this one is secured by your home.
VA and FHA have conditions of their own
A VA cash-out refinance must pass VA's net tangible benefit test, under which the new loan must deliver at least one benefit from a list federal regulation sets, such as a lower rate, a lower payment, a shorter term, an end to monthly mortgage insurance or the conversion of an adjustable rate. The lender must give you a standardized comparison of the existing loan and the proposed one on two separate occasions, early in the application and again at closing, with an estimate of the home equity being removed and an explanation of how that may affect a later sale or refinance, and you certify that you received it. VA charges a one-time funding fee, which can be financed or paid at closing and which VA waives for, among others, a veteran receiving VA disability compensation; VA publishes the rate charts, and we do not. FHA collects an up-front mortgage insurance premium, which can be financed, and an annual premium paid monthly, and HUD publishes both.