California Mortgage Solutions
Guide

How do I compare mortgage quotes and Loan Estimates?

Short answer: Compare written Loan Estimates, not quoted rates. The Loan Estimate is a standard federal form of three pages, so the same box sits in the same place on every lender's version. Ask for estimates on the same day, for the same loan amount, lock length and points or credits, then compare the loan terms, the origination charges in box A, the cash to close and the comparisons on page three.

Why the Loan Estimate is the thing to compare

A rate quoted on the phone or in an advertisement leaves out the costs that come with it. The Loan Estimate is the federal form a lender must give you after you apply, and the CFPB designed it so that every lender's version has the same pages, the same boxes and the same labels. That sameness is what makes a side by side comparison possible.

Under the federal rule, the lender must deliver or mail the Loan Estimate no later than three days after it receives your application, counting only days its offices are open for business. You do not have to accept a loan because you received or signed for an estimate.

Page one: loan terms, payments and the rate lock

The top of page one names the lender, the date issued, the loan term, the purpose, the product (fixed or adjustable, for example) and the loan type, such as conventional, FHA or VA. It also shows the rate lock status: whether the interest rate is locked and until when, and the date and time the other estimated closing costs expire. Until the rate is locked, the rate, points and lender credits can change.

The Loan Terms box lists the loan amount, the interest rate and the monthly principal and interest, and says whether each one can increase after closing. It also says whether the loan has a prepayment penalty or a balloon payment. The Projected Payments box adds mortgage insurance and estimated escrow to principal and interest, and shows estimated taxes, insurance and assessments, which of them are paid through escrow and which you pay on your own.

The Costs at Closing box at the bottom gives two totals: the estimated closing costs, made up of loan costs and other costs less any lender credits, and the estimated cash to close. Both point you to page two for the detail.

Page two: the closing cost details, box by box

The left column is Loan Costs. Box A, Origination Charges, is what the lender charges to make the loan, including any points you pay to lower the rate, and it is the box where lenders differ most directly. Box B, Services You Cannot Shop For, lists third-party services the lender chooses, such as the appraisal and the credit report. Box C, Services You Can Shop For, lists services like title work and a survey, where you may pick your own provider from the lender's list or elsewhere. Box D adds A, B and C together.

The right column is Other Costs. Box E is taxes and other government fees, such as recording fees and transfer taxes. Box F, Prepaids, is what you pay ahead at closing, such as the first homeowners insurance premium and the interest for the days just after closing. Box G, Initial Escrow Payment at Closing, is the first deposit into your escrow account for taxes and insurance. Box H, Other, holds items such as an optional owner's title policy. Box I totals E through H, and box J gives the total closing costs, with any lender credits taken off.

Below the boxes, the Calculating Cash to Close table starts from the total closing costs, then accounts for any costs financed into the loan, your down payment or funds from you, your deposit, seller credits and other adjustments, and arrives at the estimated cash to close. When they apply, page two also carries two more tables. The Adjustable Interest Rate table appears on a loan whose rate can change, and describes the index and margin, the starting rate, the minimum and maximum rate, how often it can change, and the limits on each change. The Adjustable Payment table appears when the payment can change for a reason other than the rate, such as an interest-only period or step payments.

Page three: comparisons and other considerations

Page three names the lender, any mortgage broker and the loan officers, each with an NMLS identifier, so you can look them up. The Comparisons box then gives three measures meant for setting one loan beside another. The first looks at the first several years of the loan, a fixed period the form sets, and shows the total you would have paid by then in principal, interest, mortgage insurance and loan costs, and how much principal you would have paid off. The second is the annual percentage rate, or APR, which expresses the loan's costs over its full term as a yearly rate and is not the same as the interest rate. The third is the total interest percentage, which shows the interest you would pay over the life of the loan as a share of the loan amount.

The Other Considerations box covers the appraisal (your right to a copy), whether a later buyer could assume the loan, the homeowners insurance requirement, the late payment charge, a reminder that refinancing later depends on your situation and the market, and whether the lender intends to service the loan or transfer the servicing. These do not change the costs, but they can matter as much as the costs do.

Points, lender credits and the APR: weighing the trade

A lower rate on one estimate usually has a price, and box A is where it shows. Discount points are paid at closing in exchange for a reduced interest rate, and the CFPB notes that any points listed on a Loan Estimate must, by law, be tied to a discounted rate. How much the rate drops for each point varies with the lender, the loan and the market. Some lenders also call a fee figured as a share of the loan amount points even when it does not lower the rate, so ask what each charge labeled that way actually buys.

A lender credit runs the same trade in reverse. You take a higher rate and the lender covers part of your closing costs. The credit appears on page two as a negative amount on the Lender Credits line under box J, and a lender's own worksheet may call it negative points. An offer advertised with no closing costs usually works this way and tends to bring a higher monthly payment, while an offer with no points can still carry lender fees in box A.

Which side of the trade suits you depends on how long you keep the loan. Points mean more cash out now and less over time; a credit means less now and more over time. Since nobody knows exactly when they will sell or refinance, ask the loan officer to price the same loan with points, with neither and with a credit, then compare the total cost over the shortest, the longest and the most likely stretch you might hold it. A HUD-certified housing counselor can also go through that comparison with you.

The APR folds the interest rate, points, mortgage broker fees and certain other charges into one yearly figure, which is why it usually sits above the interest rate and why it helps when two estimates trade points against rate in different ways. It has limits. On an adjustable-rate loan the APR does not reflect the highest rate the loan could reach, so the CFPB advises against setting the APR of a fixed-rate loan directly beside an adjustable one, or comparing two different adjustable loans that way. Treat it as one measure next to box A, the cash to close and the rest of page three, not as the deciding one.

The first line of the Comparisons box offers another view of the trade. Take the total you would have paid over that opening period and subtract the principal you would have paid off; what remains is your cost of borrowing for those years, and the CFPB suggests setting that amount side by side across offers.

Lenders do not set your property taxes or your homeowners insurance premium, so a smaller estimate of either on one Loan Estimate does not make that loan the better deal. When the projected escrow, the taxes and government fees, the prepaids or the initial escrow payment differ widely between estimates, ask each lender where its numbers came from, and give both the same property details.

Comparing two estimates on the same terms

Two estimates compare fairly only when they describe the same loan. Ask for them on the same day, since pricing can change from one day to the next, and for the same loan amount, the same product and loan term, the same lock length, and the same points or lender credits requested. If one estimate buys the rate down with points and the other carries a lender credit, the rate and box A will differ for that reason alone.

Then read them in order. Check page one for the same product and the lock status. On page two, compare box A first, because origination charges come from the lender itself, then box B, and look at the cash to close. On page three, compare the APR and the total interest percentage of each. Remember that boxes C, E, F, G and H depend partly on the property, the title company and the escrow, so a difference there may not reflect the lender.

When something differs and you cannot tell why, ask the lender to explain it in writing. The Closing Disclosure you receive before closing uses the same layout, so keep the Loan Estimate to compare against it.

Where to go next

Questions

How should I compare mortgage quotes from different lenders?

Compare written Loan Estimates rather than quoted rates. Ask for them on the same day, for the same loan amount, product, lock length and points or credits, then compare the loan terms on page one, the origination charges in box A, the cash to close and the comparisons on page three.

How soon does a lender have to give me a Loan Estimate?

Under the federal rule, a lender must deliver or mail the Loan Estimate no later than three days after it receives your application, counting only the days its offices are open for business. Receiving or signing for an estimate does not commit you to the loan.

Which part of the Loan Estimate shows what the lender itself charges?

Box A on page two, Origination Charges, shows what the lender charges to make the loan, including any points paid to lower the rate. It is the most direct comparison of lenders, since many of the other costs depend on the property, the title company and escrow.

What is the difference between the APR and the interest rate?

The interest rate sets the interest on your loan balance. The annual percentage rate, shown on page three of the Loan Estimate, expresses the loan's costs over its full term as a yearly rate, so it includes certain charges as well as interest. The form itself notes that the APR is not your interest rate.

What does the total interest percentage on a Loan Estimate mean?

The total interest percentage, in the Comparisons box on page three, shows the interest you would pay over the life of the loan as a share of the loan amount. It helps compare loans with different rates or structures, but it assumes you keep the loan and pay as scheduled.

Why do two Loan Estimates for the same home show different interest rates?

The estimates may have been priced on different days, with different lock lengths, or with different points or lender credits. One may buy the rate down with points while the other carries a credit. Ask both lenders for estimates on the same day and on the same terms before you compare them.

Should I pay discount points or take a lender credit?

It depends mostly on how long you expect to keep the loan. Points cost more at closing in exchange for a reduced rate, and a lender credit lowers your closing costs in exchange for a higher rate. Ask for the same loan priced with points, with neither and with a credit, and compare the total cost over the shortest, longest and most likely period you might keep it.

Does a lower APR always mean a less expensive loan?

Not always. The APR combines the interest rate with points, broker fees and certain other charges, which makes it useful for comparing similar loans. It does not show the highest rate an adjustable-rate loan could reach, and the CFPB advises against comparing a fixed-rate loan's APR directly with an adjustable one. Use it alongside the origination charges and the cash to close.

Can the numbers on my Loan Estimate change before closing?

Yes. Until the rate is locked, the rate, points and lender credits can change, and page one shows when the other estimated costs expire. Changes in the loan, the property or your application can also bring a revised estimate. The Closing Disclosure uses the same layout, so keep the estimate to compare.

Sources

The public pages this guide was read from, with the day each was read. Nothing is quoted for a figure.

Published by

California Mortgage Solutions Inc. · Company NMLS #325189 · Sources last checked

This guide is general information about preparing for a mortgage, not an offer of credit, a commitment to lend, or legal or tax advice. We are a mortgage broker, and on the loans we broker we do not underwrite; what a lender will do with a file depends on the file.

Ready to talk it through?

Start the application, ask for a quote for your own file, or call. A loan officer reads what you send and tells you what comes first.

No credit pull to get started. This is not a commitment to lend. Equal Housing Opportunity.