California Mortgage Solutions
Guide

The home appraisal: what it is and what happens if it comes in low

Short answer: An appraisal is an independent opinion of a home's market value, ordered by the lender to support the loan. The appraiser compares the home with similar recent sales nearby. You have the right to a copy. If the value comes in under the price, the contract, the seller and the lender together shape what can happen next.

Why the lender orders an appraisal

The home secures the loan, so the lender wants an independent opinion of what it is worth before it lends against it. The appraised value, together with the price, helps the lender decide how much it can lend on the property. The lender orders the appraisal, and it may ask you to pay for it.

An appraisal is not a home inspection. The appraiser estimates value and notes the home's condition as it bears on value; an inspection you arrange looks much more closely at the systems and the structure for your own information. One does not replace the other.

Appraiser independence and who regulates appraisers

Federal rules in Regulation Z protect the appraiser's independent judgment. No one with an interest in the loan may pressure, reward or instruct an appraiser to reach a particular value, and an appraiser may not have a financial interest in the property or the transaction. A lender may still ask the appraiser to consider additional information, including other comparable sales, to explain the conclusion further, or to correct an error.

In California, real estate appraisers hold a credential from the Bureau of Real Estate Appraisers, which regulates them, takes complaints about appraisers and appraisal management companies, and offers a public search where you can look up an appraiser's standing.

How comparable sales shape the value

For most homes, the appraiser looks for recent sales of similar properties nearby, called comparable sales or comps. The appraiser then adjusts for the differences between each comp and the home being appraised, such as size, condition, lot, features and location, and reconciles the adjusted figures into one opinion of value.

Because the value rests on sales that have already closed, it can trail a market that is moving quickly, and an unusual home may have few close comparisons. The report explains which sales were used and why, and that explanation is worth reading.

Your right to a copy of the appraisal

Under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act and its Regulation B, when you apply for a loan secured by a first lien on a home, the lender must give you a copy of each appraisal and other written valuation it develops for your application. It must send it promptly after it is completed, and no later than three days before closing, unless you have waived that timing.

The lender may not charge you for the copy itself, though it may charge a reasonable fee for the cost of the appraisal. If you have not received your copy, ask your lender for it.

FHA and VA appraisals, and appraisal waivers

FHA and VA loans each have property standards of their own. On those loans, the appraiser also checks that the home meets the program's basic standards for safety, soundness and livability, as well as giving an opinion of value. If the home falls short, the lender explains what the program requires before the loan can move forward.

Some loans can be approved without a full appraisal, sometimes called an appraisal waiver, when the program and the lender allow it. Whether that applies to a particular loan is the lender's decision on that file.

When the appraisal comes in low

A low appraisal means the opinion of value is less than the price you agreed to pay. Because the lender lends against the value, the gap usually has to be resolved somehow before closing. Start by reading your copy of the appraisal closely.

The general options are these. You can ask the seller to reduce the price, using the appraisal as evidence. You can cover the difference with more of your own money, if you have it and choose to. You can ask the lender for a reconsideration of value if you see a factual error or know of comparable sales the appraiser did not consider; the appraiser reviews the request and may or may not change the value. And if your purchase contract has an appraisal contingency, it may let you renegotiate or cancel within the period it sets.

Which of these is open to you depends on your contract, the seller and the lender, and none of them is certain. Ask your real estate agent or an attorney how your contract reads before a deadline passes.

Where to go next

Questions

Why does my lender need an appraisal?

The home secures the mortgage, so the lender wants an independent opinion of its market value before lending against it. The appraised value, along with the price, helps the lender decide how much it can lend on the property.

Can anyone tell the appraiser what value to reach?

No. Federal rules in Regulation Z protect the appraiser's independent judgment and bar pressuring or rewarding an appraiser to hit a value. A lender may still ask the appraiser to consider more information, explain the conclusion or correct an error.

Do I get a copy of my appraisal?

Yes. For a loan secured by a first lien on a home, the lender must give you a free copy of each appraisal and written valuation it develops for your application, promptly after completion and no later than three days before closing unless you waive that timing.

Who regulates appraisers in California?

The Bureau of Real Estate Appraisers regulates real estate appraisers in California. Appraisers hold a credential from that state agency, and it takes complaints about appraisers and appraisal management companies and offers a public appraiser search.

What are comparable sales?

Comparable sales are recent sales of similar homes nearby. The appraiser adjusts each one for differences such as size, condition, lot and features, then reconciles the adjusted figures into a single opinion of the home's market value.

What can I do if the appraisal comes in low?

The general options are to ask the seller to lower the price, to cover the difference with your own money, to ask the lender for a reconsideration of value with corrections or other comparable sales, or to use an appraisal contingency if your contract has one. None of them is certain.

Are FHA and VA appraisals different?

Yes, in one respect. Besides giving an opinion of value, an FHA or VA appraisal also checks the home against that program's own property standards for safety, soundness and livability, and shortfalls may need to be addressed before the loan moves forward.

Sources

The public pages this guide was read from, with the day each was read. Nothing is quoted for a figure.

Published by

California Mortgage Solutions Inc. · Company NMLS #325189 · Sources last checked

This guide is general information about preparing for a mortgage, not an offer of credit, a commitment to lend, or legal or tax advice. We are a mortgage broker, and on the loans we broker we do not underwrite; what a lender will do with a file depends on the file.

Ready to talk it through?

Start the application, ask for a quote for your own file, or call. A loan officer reads what you send and tells you what comes first.

No credit pull to get started. This is not a commitment to lend. Equal Housing Opportunity.