California Mortgage Solutions
Refinance

HELOC vs. cash-out refinance: how much of your mortgage needs to change?

Quick answer: A cash-out refinance replaces your whole mortgage, so its new rate applies to everything you already owe plus the cash. A home equity line of credit (HELOC) leaves the first mortgage as it is and charges interest on the amount you have drawn. When the existing balance is large and the project is paid in stages, that difference can matter more than the two advertised rates.

The most important number may be the one you already owe

An Atascadero homeowner wants money for a kitchen remodel. The cabinetmaker needs a deposit now, the contractor needs a payment when demolition finishes, and the final bill is months away. The homeowner already owes a large balance on a first mortgage, and that balance may matter more to the decision than the cost of the kitchen.

A home equity line of credit lets you borrow against a limit the lender sets, as you need to and under the plan's terms. If you keep your existing first mortgage, it keeps its own rate and terms, and the line sits behind it. A cash-out refinance replaces that mortgage with a larger loan: part pays off the old balance, and what remains after costs and any other required payoffs comes to you. The new rate then applies to every dollar of the new loan, the old balance included.

Price the dollars you will actually use

Run a simple sensitivity test before you compare advertised rates. A rate change on the whole existing balance moves far more interest than the same change on a smaller line you draw on, because the rate is multiplied by far more dollars. Even a larger rate change on the line can cost less in a year than a smaller one on the full mortgage, when the line is a small fraction of what you owe.

That test is only balance times rate. It leaves out how each loan is paid down and what each one costs to open, so treat it as a reason to ask for the full numbers, not as the answer. Comparing only the two advertised rates can send you in the wrong direction.

Match the structure to the goal

If you are paying a contractor in stages, start with a line whose draws can follow the invoices, and ask what it would cost if you drew only part of the limit in the first year.

If you want one sum at closing and have a separate reason to change the first mortgage, start with a cash-out refinance. Ask for the total interest and the remaining balance at the date you expect to sell or pay off the home.

If you are consolidating shorter-term debt, compare both structures against your current payoff schedule, and ask what you would pay in total if you repaid the moved balance on the schedule it has now. Either way, that debt becomes secured by your home, and falling behind could cost you the home through foreclosure.

Read the line's terms before you plan on it

Before a line opens, the lender must give you its written disclosures of the plan and the federal booklet on home equity lines of credit. The disclosures cover the plan's payment terms, its fees and, on a variable-rate plan, the index the rate follows and how the rate is worked out from it. Read them for how your payment is set over the life of the plan, and ask the lender for a payment example at today's rate and at a higher one.

Do not treat the undrawn part of a line as money already in hand for a construction schedule. Regulation Z lets a lender stop further borrowing or lower the limit in the circumstances it lists, among them a significant fall in the home's value and a material change in your finances. Ask the lender which of those circumstances would apply to your line.

What to check on the refinance side

For a cash-out refinance, compare the new loan's payoff date with your current one. A new loan that runs well past your current payoff date can lower the monthly payment while lengthening the time you pay interest, and the CFPB notes that a longer term generally costs more over the life of the loan. Weigh the new rate against the one on your current mortgage, too, and count the closing costs.

Whichever you lean toward, bring your current mortgage statement, the time left on the loan, the project's draw schedule and how long you expect to stay in the house. Ask each lender for a side-by-side comparison over the years you expect to stay: the combined payments, the fees, the interest, the debt left at the end and the cash received. That comparison gives you a decision you can defend even if the project changes.

Where to go next

Questions

Why does the size of my existing mortgage matter when choosing between a HELOC and a cash-out refinance?

A cash-out refinance replaces the whole mortgage, so its new rate applies to everything you already owe as well as the cash. A home equity line of credit leaves the first mortgage in place and charges interest on the amount you have drawn, so a rate change on the whole existing balance moves far more interest than the same change on a smaller line.

Is a HELOC or a cash-out refinance better for a remodel paid in stages?

Neither by rule. A line lets you draw as invoices come due and pay interest on the amount you have drawn, while a cash-out refinance pays one sum at closing. Ask what each would cost if you used only part of the money in the first year, and compare the full numbers rather than the advertised rates.

Does a cash-out refinance change the rate on my existing mortgage?

Yes. A cash-out refinance pays off the existing mortgage with a new, larger loan, and the new loan's rate and terms replace the old ones on the whole balance. A home equity line of credit leaves the existing first mortgage under its own rate and terms.

Can a lender freeze or reduce my HELOC before my project is finished?

Yes, in the circumstances Regulation Z lists, among them a significant fall in the home's value and a material change in your finances that leads the lender to believe you cannot repay. Do not count the undrawn part of a line as money already in hand for a construction schedule.

What should I read before opening a home equity line of credit?

Read the lender's written disclosures of the plan and the federal booklet on home equity lines of credit. The disclosures cover the payment terms, the fees and, on a variable-rate plan, the index and how the rate is set. Ask for a payment example at today's rate and at a higher one.

Can a cash-out refinance make me pay interest for longer?

It can. If the new loan runs past your current payoff date, the monthly payment may fall while the time you pay interest grows, and a longer term generally costs more over the life of the loan. Compare the new payoff date with your current one before deciding.

Sources

The public pages this article was read from, with the day each was read. Nothing is quoted for a figure.

Published by

California Mortgage Solutions Inc. · Company NMLS #325189 · Sources last checked

This article is general information, not an offer of credit, a commitment to lend, or legal or tax advice. What a lender will do with a file depends on the file, and the programs named here set their own rules.

Want to talk through your own situation?

Start the application, ask for a quote for your own file, or call. A loan officer reads what you send and tells you what comes first.

No credit pull to get started. This is not a commitment to lend. Equal Housing Opportunity.