California Mortgage Solutions
Buying

Underfunded HOA reserves: what California buyers should review before releasing contingencies

Quick answer: In a California condo or townhome community, the association's reserve study and its funding summary say more about future costs than this month's dues. State law has the seller hand you the budget report, the reserve disclosures and a statement of current and approved assessments, plus a year of board minutes if you ask. Read them before you release your contingencies, and tell your loan officer about any dues increase.

Why the reserves matter as much as the dues

A homeowners association collects regular assessments for two jobs. One is running the community from month to month. The other is saving for the large repairs and replacements the association is responsible for, such as roofs, exterior paint, paving and shared equipment. That savings is the reserve account, and a low monthly due can simply mean the saving has not kept pace.

California's Department of Real Estate has warned buyers about associations without enough money set aside. When the common areas cannot be kept up, roads, pools, paint and roofs can fall into disrepair, and an association short of funds often turns to a special assessment charged to every owner. A buyer who never looks at the association's finances can be the one caught by that bill.

This is general information, not legal advice. Whether to stay in a contract or walk away is your decision, made with your real estate agent and, if you want one, your own attorney.

Step one: get the documents California law lists

California's Civil Code requires the seller of a unit in a common interest development to give a prospective buyer a set of documents as soon as practicable before title transfers. For questions about money, three items on that list carry the most weight.

The first is the most recent annual budget report package. The second is a written statement from the association of the current regular and special assessments and fees, along with any increase the board has approved that is not yet due. The third, if you ask for it, is a copy of the board's approved meeting minutes from the past year, leaving out executive sessions. The minutes are the item buyers most often forget to request, so put that request in writing early.

What the annual budget report has to contain

Unless the association's own rules demand more, the budget report includes an operating budget, a summary of the reserves, and a summary of the board's reserve funding plan. It also states whether the board has decided to put off or skip the repair or replacement of any major component, with the board's reason, and whether the board expects a special assessment to be needed. When one is expected, the report gives its estimated size, start and length.

The budget report must come with a one-page form called the Assessment and Reserve Funding Disclosure Summary. For a condominium project, the report also carries a separate statement of whether the project is approved by the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) and by the Department of Veterans Affairs, which matters if your loan is FHA or VA.

The summary tells members that the full reserve study plan is available on request. A buyer is not yet a member, so ask your agent to request the complete study through the seller rather than relying on the summary alone.

Step two: read the reserve study and the funding summary

On a regular schedule the statute sets, the board has to arrange a visual inspection of the accessible parts of the major components the association must maintain, as part of a study of its reserve needs, and it has to review that study every year. The study lists those components, estimates how long each has left and what each will cost to repair or replace, and lays out a plan for paying for the work.

The disclosure summary then asks the board a direct question: based on the latest study, will the projected reserve balances be enough, year by year over the coming decades, to cover the repair and replacement of major components? If the answer is no, the form asks what additional assessments or contributions would close the gap. It also compares the reserve balance the association expects to hold with the amount its formula says it should hold, which shows how much of the estimated need the reserves cover.

The form itself says its figures are the preparer's estimates and can change. A thin reserve or a no on the sufficiency question is a reason to keep reading, not a verdict on the community by itself.

Step three: check planned work, assessments and the minutes

Look for a special assessment the board has already approved or expects to levy, any decision to defer the repair of a major component and the reason given, and any approved increase in the regular dues that has not started yet. Then read the minutes. Contractor bids, roof or balcony discussions and arguments over the dues often appear there long before they reach a budget.

Walk the property too. The Department of Real Estate suggests looking at the exterior paint, the amenities, the roads, roofs, drives and fencing. Wear that shows from the parking lot is often work the reserves will have to pay for.

Step four: tell your loan officer about dues changes

Association dues are part of the monthly housing expense a lender weighs against your income, and Fannie Mae's Selling Guide lists special assessments in that expense as well. A dues increase or a newly planned assessment can therefore change the numbers on a loan that already looked settled, so pass the statement from the association to your loan officer as soon as you have it.

Some loan programs also review the condominium project itself, separately from you. An FHA loan, for example, generally needs either a project on the FHA approved list or an approval of the single unit. Ask early which review your loan will need, because the documents in this article are many of the same ones that review uses.

Asking for a seller credit, renegotiating the price or cancelling under a contingency are choices for you and your agent, inside your contract's deadlines. A loan officer here can help you see how a new dues figure fits the loan review; whether the association is a sound place to own is a judgment that stays yours.

Where to go next

Questions

What is an HOA reserve study?

A reserve study is a periodic look at the major components a homeowners association must repair or replace, such as roofs and paving. It estimates how long each has left and what each will cost, and sets out a plan to pay for the work. In California the board must have it done on a schedule the statute sets and review it every year.

Which HOA documents must a California seller give a buyer?

Under the Civil Code, the seller provides the governing documents, the most recent annual budget report package with its reserve disclosures, and a written statement of current and approved assessments, among other items. On the buyer's request, the seller also provides the board's approved meeting minutes from the past year, executive sessions excluded.

What should I do if the HOA reserves look low?

Keep reading rather than deciding on one number. Look at the reserve funding plan, any statement that the board is deferring repairs, any expected special assessment and the past year of board minutes, then talk with your agent about your options under the contract. Low reserves raise the chance of a special assessment later.

Do higher HOA dues affect my mortgage?

They can. Association dues, and special assessments, count in the monthly housing expense a lender compares with your income, so a dues increase can change whether the loan still fits. Give your loan officer the association's statement of assessments as soon as you receive it.

Can a buyer see the HOA board minutes?

Yes, if the buyer asks. California's Civil Code has the seller provide copies of the board meeting minutes from the past year that the board has approved, leaving out executive sessions. Make the request in writing early, because the minutes often show planned projects before a budget does.

What is the Assessment and Reserve Funding Disclosure Summary?

It is a short form California requires with each HOA annual budget report. It lists the regular assessment and any scheduled special assessments, asks whether projected reserves will be enough to cover major repairs in the decades ahead, and compares the reserve balance with the amount the association's formula says it needs. Its figures are estimates.

Sources

The public pages this article was read from, with the day each was read. Nothing is quoted for a figure.

Published by

California Mortgage Solutions Inc. · Company NMLS #325189 · Sources last checked

This article is general information, not an offer of credit, a commitment to lend, or legal or tax advice. What a lender will do with a file depends on the file, and the programs named here set their own rules.

Want to talk through your own situation?

Start the application, ask for a quote for your own file, or call. A loan officer reads what you send and tells you what comes first.

No credit pull to get started. This is not a commitment to lend. Equal Housing Opportunity.