California Mortgage Solutions
Investors

Investment property mortgages in California: how a conventional lender counts your rental income

Quick answer: On a conventional loan that follows Fannie Mae's Selling Guide, rent is not simply added to your pay. The lender documents the rent from your tax return or, in listed cases, a lease, converts it to net rental income, and subtracts the property's full payment. A positive result can add to your income only if you have a record of managing rentals.

Why rent is not counted like a paycheck

An investor in Paso Robles owns one rental that shows a loss on last year's tax return and is buying a second one with a tenant already in place. The rent looks healthy on both. The lender's figure, though, may look nothing like the rent checks, because Fannie Mae's Selling Guide has its own method for each property.

This article covers conventional loans underwritten to that guide. It is general education, not tax or legal advice, and it does not describe DSCR loans or other programs outside the agency rules, which follow each lender's own terms. Individual lenders can also add stricter requirements of their own, so treat the guide as the starting point for your file.

What makes a property an investment property

Fannie Mae recognizes three occupancy types: a principal residence, a second home and an investment property. An investment property is one you do not live in as your principal residence or second home, including a property held or operated mainly as a rental. If you plan to live in the property for any part of the year, say so at the start, because the occupancy type changes which documents are needed and which loans fit.

The guide also adds a price adjustment to every loan it buys that is secured by an investment property, and it has these loans run through its automated underwriting system. What that adjustment means for the rate or cost of your own loan depends on the lender and on the full file.

Where the lender gets the rent figure

For a rental you already own, the starting point is your most recent signed individual federal tax return, including Schedule E. A lease can stand in for the return only in listed situations: you are buying a property with a lease that transfers to you, you bought the rental during or after the period your last return covers, a major interruption such as a renovation kept rent off that return, the property was first rented this calendar year, or the lender documents another situation that justifies it.

For the property you are buying or refinancing, the appraiser prepares a comparable rent schedule. If market rents do not reasonably support the rent on the lease or on Schedule E, the guide has the lender gather more documentation, write an analysis explaining why the higher rent is stable, or use the lower figure.

How the rent becomes qualifying income

Fannie Mae calls the result adjusted net rental income, and the method depends on the documents. On a purchase, or for a rental not yet on your Schedule E, the lender counts only part of the gross rent on the lease or rent schedule, a share the guide sets, and then subtracts the property's full monthly payment: principal, interest, property taxes, insurance and any association dues (PITIA). For a rental already on Schedule E, the lender runs a cash flow analysis of that schedule, averages it over the months the guide calls for, and subtracts the same full payment.

The cash flow analysis is where a paper loss can change. The lender adds back the depreciation, mortgage interest, association dues, taxes and insurance shown on Schedule E, and it may add back a documented one-time repair. A rental that showed a loss for tax purposes can still produce positive rental income for the loan, which is a reason to have the actual returns reviewed before you decide a conventional loan will not work.

For a rental other than your own home, a positive result is added to your monthly income and a negative result is added to your monthly debts in the debt-to-income ratio. Because that rental's full payment is already inside the calculation, it is not counted a second time. The payment on the home you live in still counts as a debt. If you own several rentals, each is figured on its own and the results are combined.

The property management record

Fannie Mae lets positive rental income count fully only when the borrower has a minimum record of managing rental property, a period the guide sets. A recent signed return showing a full year of fair rental days, a partnership or S corporation return reporting the rental, or in some cases a signed lease of the required length can establish that record.

Without that record, positive rental income from a property can offset that property's own full payment, and nothing beyond it. A negative result counts against your debt-to-income ratio either way. A first-time landlord's other income has to carry the rest of the qualification.

What the lender wants to see in a lease

When a lease is used for a property that is not on your most recent return, it cannot be with a family member or with someone who has an interest in the sale. The lender also confirms the lease is really in effect: usually with recent bank statements or transfers showing rent that matches the lease; for a newly signed lease, the security deposit and the first full month's rent; or a property management agreement with an unrelated manager plus proof of the recent rent.

A newly signed lease on a property not yet on your return has a minimum term the guide sets, with the first rent due by the first payment on the new mortgage. The rent must be stated in U.S. dollars, not in a virtual currency. Where the deposits and the lease amount differ, expect to explain why in writing.

The rest of an investment property review

Reserves are one more layer. Fannie Mae adds reserve requirements for second homes and investment properties that grow with the number of financed properties you will own, and it limits how many financed properties one borrower may have on these loans. Rent reported through a partnership or an S corporation is evaluated as self-employment income, using the business return.

Gather your recent signed federal returns with every schedule, a current lease for each rental, bank statements that show the rent arriving, the mortgage, tax, insurance and association statements for each property you own, any management agreement, and the business returns for any rental held in a partnership or S corporation.

When a conventional loan may not fit

If your returns show heavy write-offs, or you are adding properties quickly, a conventional review may count less of your rent than you expect. A DSCR loan, which looks mainly at whether the property's rent covers its payment, is one alternative. Its ratio, rent sources and terms are set by each lender rather than by an agency guide, so compare it against a conventional review of the same file.

To start, bring your returns, your leases and a list of the properties you own to a first conversation with a loan officer here.

Where to go next

Questions

Can I use the rent from a property I am buying to qualify for a conventional loan?

On a one- to four-unit investment property, Fannie Mae's guide allows it. The appraiser's comparable rent schedule supports the rent, the lender counts a set share of it and subtracts the full monthly payment, and it documents your current housing payment. A positive result counts fully only with a record of managing rentals.

Will the lender use my lease or my tax return for rental income?

Usually the tax return with Schedule E comes first. A lease is used in listed situations, such as a rental bought after your last return, a property first rented this calendar year, a renovation that kept rent off your last return, or a purchase with a lease that transfers to you.

Why does a Schedule E loss not tell the whole story for a mortgage?

Fannie Mae's cash flow method adds back depreciation, mortgage interest, association dues, taxes and insurance shown on Schedule E, and may add back a documented one-time expense, before subtracting the property's full payment. The lender's rental income figure can therefore be higher than the bottom line on your return.

Can a first-time landlord count rental income on a mortgage?

Partly. Without the minimum record of managing rentals that Fannie Mae's guide sets, positive rental income from a property can offset only that property's own full payment and cannot add to your income. A negative result still counts as a debt, so your other income has to carry the rest.

How is a rental counted in my debt-to-income ratio?

For a rental that is not your home, the lender subtracts the property's full payment from its qualifying rent. A positive result is added to your income and a negative one to your monthly debts, without counting that payment twice. Your own home's payment is always a debt, and each rental is figured separately.

Is a DSCR loan easier than a conventional loan for a rental?

Not automatically. A DSCR loan sits outside the agency rules, and each lender sets its own ratio, rent source and terms. Some investors look at one when their tax returns show less income than the property produces, but compare its cost against a conventional review of the same file first.

Sources

The public pages this article was read from, with the day each was read. Nothing is quoted for a figure.

Published by

California Mortgage Solutions Inc. · Company NMLS #325189 · Sources last checked

This article is general information, not an offer of credit, a commitment to lend, or legal or tax advice. What a lender will do with a file depends on the file, and the programs named here set their own rules.

Want to talk through your own situation?

Start the application, ask for a quote for your own file, or call. A loan officer reads what you send and tells you what comes first.

No credit pull to get started. This is not a commitment to lend. Equal Housing Opportunity.