California Mortgage Solutions
Veterans

The VA appraisal and the home inspection: two different checks

Quick answer: The VA appraisal and a home inspection are separate steps done for different reasons. The lender arranges the appraisal, which gives a value and checks the home against VA's minimum property requirements. You hire the inspector, who looks closely at the home's condition for you. VA says an appraisal is not an inspection and strongly recommends getting one.

Two checks, two different questions

The appraisal answers a question for the loan: what is this home reasonably worth, and does it meet the basic standards VA sets for a home it backs part of a loan on? Those standards are VA's minimum property requirements. The lender arranges the appraisal with a VA appraiser after you have a signed purchase agreement.

The inspection answers a question for you: what condition is the home in, and what may need repair or replacement soon? You choose and hire the inspector, and the report is yours. The CFPB's advice is to pick an inspector who is accountable to you, not to anyone else in the sale.

VA is direct about the difference. Its home buying page says an appraisal is not the same as an inspection, and its quick reference for real estate professionals says a VA appraisal does not serve as one. VA does not require an inspection, and it strongly recommends getting one.

What the VA appraisal covers, and what it leaves out

The appraiser gives an opinion of the home's value and notes whether the home meets the minimum property requirements. When it does not, the appraisal lists what has to be addressed, and the lender works from that list. VA's guidance for real estate professionals also says a buyer can ask the lender whether a waiver of a particular requirement is possible.

The minimum property requirements are a floor for the loan, not a full report on the house. A home can meet them and still have an aging roof, an old water heater or a drainage problem that a closer look would find. That gap is the reason VA recommends the inspection.

The requirements also change over time. VA revised them in a recent update to its Lenders Handbook, removing some older rules and updating others, and said the changes were meant to cut outdated rules and reduce delays. Ask the lender which version applies to your file.

What the home inspection covers

An inspector looks at the home's systems and structure and gives you a written report. The CFPB suggests scheduling the inspection as soon as you choose a home, so there is time to deal with what it finds or to order a more specialized inspection, and going along if you can, so the report is easier to follow and you can ask questions on the spot.

What the inspection finds is information for you. It can support a request that the seller repair something, lower the price or give a credit toward the cost, depending on your contract and the seller's answer.

Put both checks in your contract plan

A VA purchase contract includes a clause, which VA's home buying page calls the VA option clause, that lets you void the contract if the home does not appraise for the price. That clause is about value. It says nothing about what the inspector finds.

To be able to step away over the inspection results, ask your real estate agent about an inspection contingency. VA's home buying page names this kind of contingency, and the CFPB notes that with one in the contract you can cancel without penalty if you are not satisfied with the results. Your agent can explain how your own contract words it and how long it lasts.

If the appraisal comes in below the price

VA's home buying page lists three ways forward. Your agent or lender can ask for a reconsideration of value, sending sales of similar homes that support a higher figure. You can renegotiate the price with the seller. Or you can pay the difference between the price and the appraised value yourself, if you choose to and can. The option clause is the way out of the contract if none of those works.

VA also describes a step that can come before the appraisal is final. When the appraiser expects the value may fall short of the price, the contact named on the appraisal order is told and can send more sales data. VA calls this the Tidewater Initiative.

Paying above the appraised value deserves care. The CFPB puts it plainly: it is very risky to buy a home for more than its appraised value.

If the appraisal or the inspection calls for repairs

Repairs the appraisal lists are conditions of the loan. The CFPB notes that for major repairs a lender can require the work to be done before closing, or can have money set aside to pay for it right after. Who pays for and arranges the work is settled between you and the seller in the contract.

Repairs the inspection suggests are yours to weigh. Some may be worth asking the seller to handle, some may be worth a credit, and some you may decide to take on after you move in.

An order of steps that works

Get your Certificate of Eligibility and talk with a lender before you shop. When you make an offer, check that the contract has the VA option clause and ask your agent about an inspection contingency. Schedule the inspection right away. The lender arranges the appraisal.

When both reports are in, read them side by side before you decide the next step. A copy of the appraisal is yours: the CFPB says that for most first mortgages you are entitled to a copy of the appraisals the lender gets, promptly and before closing.

Where to go next

Questions

Is a home inspection required for a VA loan?

No. VA does not require a home inspection, but it strongly recommends one, and it says the VA appraisal is not an inspection. The appraisal is for the loan; the inspection is for you.

Does the VA appraisal check the home for problems?

Only against VA's minimum property requirements, the basic standards a home needs to meet for a VA loan. Repairs needed to meet them are listed for the lender. A home inspection is a much closer look at the home's systems and condition.

Who orders the VA appraisal and the home inspection?

The lender arranges the VA appraisal with a VA appraiser. You choose and hire the home inspector yourself. Ask the lender and your agent how each fee is handled in your purchase.

What if the VA appraisal comes in below the purchase price?

VA's home buying page lists three options: ask for a reconsideration of value with sales data that supports a higher figure, renegotiate the price with the seller, or pay the difference yourself if you choose to. The VA option clause lets you void the contract if the home does not appraise.

Does the VA option clause cover problems the inspection finds?

No. The option clause is tied to the appraised value. To be able to cancel over inspection results, ask your real estate agent about an inspection contingency in your purchase contract.

Sources

The public pages this article was read from, with the day each was read. Nothing is quoted for a figure.

Published by

California Mortgage Solutions Inc. · Company NMLS #325189 · Sources last checked

This article is general information, not an offer of credit, a commitment to lend, or legal or tax advice. What a lender will do with a file depends on the file, and the programs named here set their own rules.

Want to talk through your own situation?

Start the application, ask for a quote for your own file, or call. A loan officer reads what you send and tells you what comes first.

No credit pull to get started. This is not a commitment to lend. Equal Housing Opportunity.